Sugar Season 2 — Science Fiction, Noir, or Both?

Send us Fan Mail

Greg Dyro and Tom Burka return to the strange, stylish world of Apple TV’s Sugar for a look at Season 2 and one of the most unusual detective shows on television.

At first glance, Sugar has all the ingredients of classic Los Angeles noir: a private detective, missing people, wealthy families with secrets, dangerous characters, shadowy motives, vintage movies, cool cars, and a city where almost everyone seems to be hiding something. But Sugar has never been quite what it appears to be.

So what exactly are we watching in Season 2?

Is Sugar fundamentally a science-fiction series wrapped inside a noir detective story? Or, now that the show’s biggest secret is out, is it really a traditional detective drama with a science-fiction element operating quietly in the background?

Greg and Tom dig into that question while discussing Colin Farrell’s John Sugar, the season’s mysteries, characters, twists, visual style, and the show’s continuing fascination with classic Hollywood and detective movies. We look at what works, what doesn’t, and whether the unusual combination of genres makes Sugar more compelling—or occasionally gets in the way of a perfectly good mystery.

We also ponder some bigger questions raised by the series: What makes John Sugar different from the detectives who inspired him? How important is the science fiction to understanding the character? And after two seasons, what kind of television show has Sugar actually become?

It’s part review, part genre debate, part Hollywood discussion—and, inevitably, a healthy dose of serious nonsense.

Join Greg and Tom as they try to decide whether Sugar Season 2 is science fiction, neo-noir, a detective story, or something that refuses to fit neatly into any of those categories.

Movie Reviews and Serious Nonsense — with Greg Dyro and Tom Burka

Movie Reviews and Serious Nonsense is a King Dyro Production ©2026